Category Air Warfare

More AI on Kurt Vonnegut

Jay Karamales, the co-author of The Hunting Falcon, asked Copilot AI the same question. I pick up his narrative here:

“It replied (in its long-winded way, which I excerpt here):

“No—they could not have known each other.

Buddecke died in 1918, and Vonnegut wasn’t born until 1922.”

Fair enough. Then, with hopes soaring, I asked:
 
“So their lives were not contiguous and they didn’t know each other; but were they related?”
 
Sadly, its answer:
 
“No—they were not related.
They belonged to entirely different families, countries, and social contexts, with no known genealogical or historical connection.”
 
Oh well. I guess, like all but about 15 of the Earth’s population, it has not read our book. I will ask Grok the same questions when I get home tonight.”
 
Anyhow, he (Jay Karamales) posted his comments to the previous blog post, but I (Chris Lawrence) choose to report in a separate blog post, seeing how AI is supposed to replace us all and take over the world.
 
Part of its (Copilot) confusion is that it assumed Kurt Vonnegut Jr. Almost certainly Hans Buddecke knew Kurt Vonnegut, Sr. He was a regular visitor to the Albert Lieber household and came to the United States according to his account with the encouragement of tall beauty Edith Lieber. She married Kurt Vonnegut in November 1913 and had their first child (the famous scientist, but not as famous as his younger brother) Bernard Vonnegut on 29 August 1914. Hans Buddecke never met Bernard Vonnegut, having started in trip back to Germany in early August, but he certainly knew of him.
 
That is the problem. AI does not read books. Books are protected in the U.S. by a 70-year copyright law. So anything that has been written about in the last 70 years is not available to AI unless it has been reposted in some form on the internet. Most authors have other things to do with their time (other than service AI).
 
AI also does not go to the archives either. Apparently does not search the on-line newspaper files, which would show that Lieber and Buddecke are related and working together in 1914. In particular is the article in The Indianapolis News, Friday 31 July 1914 “Birdman Flies over Western Part of City”, which identified “Johann Buddecke” and “…his uncle, Albert Lieber.”
 
 

The Hunting Falcon and Kurt Vonnegut and AI

One of our discoveries in researching for the book The Hunting Falcon was that Hans Buddecke’s uncle-by-marriage that he was working with in Indianapolis in 1913/1914 was Indianapolis businessman and brewer Albert Lieber. Albert Lieber was the grandfather of Kurt Vonnegut Jr. (i.e. Slaughterhouse Five, Cat’s Cradle, etc.).

Now in a discussion with my co-author Jay Karamales over the 6.65 pounds in royalties we have made from the book from July 2025 – December 2025, I decided to check if AI had picked up on our findings. After all, while the financial reimbursement for writing is not overwhelming, the emotional rewards more than compensate, especially as our work on the Hunting Falcon was new and original research. We could make more money working at McDonalds (“would you like fries with that”) than we do from writing 

So I asked Yahoo AI: “Did Hans Buddecke know Kurt Vonnegut?” It’s  response:

“Hans Buddecke and Kurt Vonnegut are connected through family. Buddecke was the grandfather of Kurt Vonnegut Jr. This familial link suggests that while they did not know each other personally (as Buddecke died in 1918 and Vonnegut was born in 1922), their lives are intertwined through family history.”

No…. he was not Kurt Vonnegut’s grandfather. Do not know how AI determined that. They, of course, reference a blog post from this site: WWI Air – The Dupuy Institute

Now, suspect they had some problem with my wording, which was: 

“Hans-Joachim Buddecke’s story starts before the war in Indianapolis, working for his American uncle (later the grandfather of author Kurt Vonnegut Jr.)….”

Anyhow, one must cross-check everything you get from AI. I have not asked this question to other AI (probably should, but Yahoo AI is the one I used for data quieries).

As far as I know, we are the only source that connects German ace Hans Buddecke with Kurt Vonnegut. 

On the other hand, I did have fun asking Yahoo AI who was the leader in historical analysis. But it also makes a factual error in that response.

French Air Power 1918-1940: Politics

The seventh of a series of eight presentations on French Air Power 1918 – 1940 by Dr. James Slaughter is this Wednesday, 10 June, 7:00 PM (EST) via Zoom.

The Zoom link is here:

https://us06web.zoom.us/j/82312904908?pwd=hThCR8854TXLDessozm3w8MrUNydYW.1

The whole series is here: French Air Power 1918-1940 – The Dupuy Institute

 

The call for presentations for the Fifth HAAC is here: Call for Presentations for the Fifth HAAC, 20 – 22 October 2026 – The Dupuy Institute

The schedule for the Fifth HAAC is rapidly filling in. Now is a good time to commit: HAAC 2026: Fifth Historical Analysis Annual Conference (HAAC) – The Dupuy Institute

Just email me at LawrenceTDI@aol.com is you want to sign up for a presentation.

The sign-up for Fifth HAAC is here: Fifth Historical Analysis Annual Conference (HAAC) Tickets, Tuesday, October 20  •  8 AM – 6 PM | Eventbrite

I have received my copies of Operation Spider’s Web

I have received my six author copies of Operation Spider’s Web. The book is available in the UK at bookstores and on Amazon.com (UK). It will be available in the U.S. at bookstores and on Amazon.com come 30 July.

Got a few pictures of it:

 

With the exception of America’s Modern Wars (my most significant book), we do not sell any of my books directly. We do sell several of Trevor Dupuy books directly: Understanding War (his most significant book), Elusive Victory (still the best book on the Arab-Israeli Wars), Brave Men and Great Captains, Understanding Defeat, Future Wars, Harper Encyclopedia of Military Biography, Military Heritage of America (volume 2), If War Comes, Hitler’s Last Gamble (in Japanese) and A Genius for War. We are out of Attrition and Numbers, Predictions and War. See: Books – The Dupuy Institute

French Air Power: The Spanish Civil War

The sixth of a series of eight presentations on French Air Power 1918 – 1940 by Dr. James Slaughter is this Wednesday, 27 May, 7:00 PM (EST) via Zoom.

The Zoom link is here:

https://us06web.zoom.us/j/87873302892?pwd=CxXR7quHmysDYl6S8xeOM73qDo6KwI.1

The whole series is here: French Air Power 1918-1940 – The Dupuy Institute




 

 

The call for presentations for the Fifth HAAC is here: Call for Presentations for the Fifth HAAC, 20 – 22 October 2026 – The Dupuy Institute

The schedule for the Fifth HAAC is rapidly filling in. Now is a good time to commit: HAAC 2026: Fifth Historical Analysis Annual Conference (HAAC) – The Dupuy Institute

Just email me at LawrenceTDI@aol.com is you want to sign up for a presentation.

The sign-up for Fifth HAAC is here: Fifth Historical Analysis Annual Conference (HAAC) Tickets, Tuesday, October 20  •  8 AM – 6 PM | Eventbrite

Operation Spider’s Web released in UK

My latest book Operation Spider’s Web: Ukraine’s Devastating Drone Attack on Russia’s Long-Range Aircraft has been released in the UK.

The link is here: Pen and Sword Books: Operation Spider’s Web – Hardback

The UK Amazon.com link is here: Operation Spider’s Web: Ukraine’s Devastating Drone Attack on Russia’s Long-Range Aircraft: Amazon.co.uk: Christopher A Lawrence: 9781036196738: Books

It is available in the UK in hardcover. The kindle edition will be available before 30 July in the U.S. and UK.  The hardcover version has a release date in the U.S. of 30 July 2026.

This is my third book on the Russo-Ukrainian War (Kyiv, Mariupol and now Operation Spider’s Web). Working on more. 

French Air Power: Doctrine and Intelligence 1934 – 1940

The fifth of a series of eight presentations on French Air Power 1918 – 1940 by Dr. James Slaughter is this Wednesday, 13 May, 7:00 PM (EST) via Zoom.

The Zoom link is here:

https://us06web.zoom.us/j/83581419598?pwd=V2Pncrzxk686uy6ahVa7lT0M8GVPSu.1

The whole series is here: French Air Power 1918-1940 – The Dupuy Institute

The Morane D-3801 (from Switzerland late 1940).
At the Duxford Airshow 2006 (photo by Kogo)


The call for presentations for the Fifth HAAC is here: Call for Presentations for the Fifth HAAC, 20 – 22 October 2026 – The Dupuy Institute

The schedule for the Fifth HAAC is rapidly filling in. Now is a good time to commit: HAAC 2026: Fifth Historical Analysis Annual Conference (HAAC) – The Dupuy Institute

Just email me at LawrenceTDI@aol.com is you want to sign up for a presentation.

The sign-up for Fifth HAAC is here: Fifth Historical Analysis Annual Conference (HAAC) Tickets, Tuesday, October 20  •  8 AM – 6 PM | Eventbrite

French Air Power: Aircraft and Industry 1934 to 1940

The fourth of a series of eight presentations on French Air Power 1918 – 1940 by Dr. James Slaughter is this Wednesday, 29 April, 7:00 PM (EST) via Zoom.

The Zoom link is here:

https://us06web.zoom.us/j/86389557188?pwd=CqKeUajYxXiiw8al9FqrtBCXTbUfzC.1

The whole series is here: French Air Power 1918-1940 – The Dupuy Institute

The Morane D-3801 (from Switzerland late 1940).
At the Duxford Airshow 2006 (photo by Kogo)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The call for presentations for the Fifth HAAC is here: Call for Presentations for the Fifth HAAC, 20 – 22 October 2026 – The Dupuy Institute

The schedule for the Fifth HAAC is rapidly filling in. Now is a good time to commit: HAAC 2026: Fifth Historical Analysis Annual Conference (HAAC) – The Dupuy Institute

Just email me at LawrenceTDI@aol.com is you want to sign up for a presentation.

The sign-up for Fifth HAAC is here: Fifth Historical Analysis Annual Conference (HAAC) Tickets, Tuesday, October 20  •  8 AM – 6 PM | Eventbrite

French Air Power: Late 20s and Air Force Independence – this Wednesday

The third of a series of eight presentations on French Air Power 1918 – 1940 by Dr. James Slaughter is this Wednesday, 15 April, 7:00 PM (EST) via Zoom.

The Zoom link is here: https://us06web.zoom.us/j/82767463706?pwd=qSJpzw2OiCr61CCRZ0f6nSVz5tzRCN.1

The whole series is here: French Air Power 1918-1940 – The Dupuy Institute

The call for presentations for the Fifth HAAC is here: Call for Presentations for the Fifth HAAC, 20 – 22 October 2026 – The Dupuy Institute

The schedule for the Fifth HAAC is rapidly filling in. Now is a good time to commit: HAAC 2026: Fifth Historical Analysis Annual Conference (HAAC) – The Dupuy Institute

Just email me at LawrenceTDI@aol.com is you want to sign up for a presentation.

The sign-up for Fifth HAAC is here: Fifth Historical Analysis Annual Conference (HAAC) Tickets, Tuesday, October 20  •  8 AM – 6 PM | Eventbrite

French Air Power: 20s and the Rif War – this Wednesday

The second of a series of eight presentations on French Air Power 1918 – 1940 by Dr. James Slaughter for real this Wednesday, 1 April, 7:00 PM (EST) via Zoom.

The Zoom link is here: https://us06web.zoom.us/j/89471662474?pwd=IIoobuk6pNyRvyjnSodlgKaHnFqgEY.1

The whole series is here: French Air Power 1918-1940 – The Dupuy Institute

The call for presentations for the Fifth HAAC is here: Call for Presentations for the Fifth HAAC, 20 – 22 October 2026 – The Dupuy Institute

 

Le chef riffain [i.e. rifain] Kaid Sarkash et son fils armés avec des Mausers capturés aux Espagnols : [photographie de presse] / [Agence Rol] : vue 1 – Le chef riffain [i.e. rifain] Kaid Sarkash et son fils armés avec des Mausers capturés aux Espagnols : [photographie de presse] / [Agence Rol].

 

English: Sketch map of Northern Morocco during the first half of the 1920s focussing on the theatre of war during the Rif War. The map shows the limits of the Riffian republic, with Spanish-occupied territory at both end (shaded areas).
Riffian control had spilled over inside French Morocco; the dots represents French fortifications (“blockhaus”) built to contain the Berber tribesmen who, the French feared, threatened Fez for a time. This map is contained in Pierre Sémard’s book “La guerre du Rif” published in 1926.